You’ve got the qualifications. You’ve made it to multiple final-round interviews. Your resume opens doors. But the offer never comes. Why? Let’s dig in…
As a career coach, I’ve seen this happen time and time again — and the reasons often have less to do with your background and more to do with how you communicate it. Here are five common barriers that keep even the strongest candidates from sealing the deal — and how to overcome them.
- Lack of Clear, Compelling Storytelling
The Problem: Candidates give answers that are too vague, too technical, or underwhelming.
The Fix:
- Use the STAR method: Situation, Task, Action, Result.
- Emphasize the Result every time.
- Practice “before and after” framing: What was broken? What did you fix? What changed because of you?
- Use this phrase: “What this achieved was…”
🧠 Coach Garrison Tip: Build a personal bank of 5 impact stories you can flex across behavioral questions.
- Weak Executive Presence or Confidence
The Problem: You may sound unsure, overly modest, or lack vocal presence.
The Fix:
- Record yourself answering questions to hear tone, pacing, and body language.
- Pause and smile before answering — this builds control and warmth.
- Own your impact. You’re the expert in your own success.
🧠 Coach Garrison Tip: “People hire energy, not just experience. You need to make them believe you can lead others and influence outcomes.”
- Not Connecting the Dots for the Employer
The Problem: The interviewer can’t see how your experience applies to their exact role.
The Fix:
- Tailor your responses to the company’s context. Use their terminology (e.g., “MLR review,” “sales enablement,” “regulated product marketing”).
- End responses with a direct connection:
“That’s why I believe my experience launching regulated products and collaborating with cross-functional teams would translate well to this role at XYZ.”
- Practice turning resume bullets into “why this matters to you” statements.
- Weak Responses to “Soft” Questions
The Problem: You stumble on questions like “Why us?”, “What motivates you?”, or “What’s your weakness?”
The Fix:
- Prepare values-based personal stories that show insight and self-awareness.
- Go beyond surface-level for “Why this company?” — connect with their mission and innovation.
- Choose a real weakness you’ve improved. For example:
“Early in my career, I was overly focused on execution. I’ve learned to step back, ask better strategic questions, and lead with the big picture.”
- No Closing Power
The Problem: You don’t end strong — and leave a forgettable impression.
The Fix:
- Close interviews with confidence. Example:
“Thank you for the conversation. I’m excited about the opportunity to contribute at XYZ. I’m confident that my track record in regulated product launches and my passion for innovation would allow me to make an immediate impact.”
- Send a tailored thank-you note that references something discussed during the interview.
Final Thought
You don’t need to be perfect to get the offer — but you do need to connect the dots, tell your story with impact, and show them why you’re the solution they’ve been waiting for. The interview is your moment. Step into it with clarity and confidence.
If you’re not getting the offer, it’s not too late — it’s just time to shift your strategy.